India’s Mobile Market

I was at Wharton recently, and Knowledge@Wharton set up a “Five Questions” discussion between Kevin Werbach and me. Here is what part of the exchange went.

Kevin Werbach: I’m very interested in learning from you more about the market in India, where you have been active. Could you talk about how the Internet market and the communications market in India are different from the United States or other countries in the West?

Rajesh Jain: The market in India is dominated by mobile. For mobile we have 400 million-plus users. Internet has been more stagnant in the last year or year and a half at about 45 million to 50 million. So what’s happening is that, unlike many other markets, mobile is becoming the dominant device for voice, for value-added services, and increasingly for mobile Internet also. It’s somewhat similar to what we saw in Japan in 1999 where, because of the limitation of broadband and computing, basically i-mode, the service which DoCoMo launched, became the center of people’s lives. Mobile is already becoming that. There’s a whole host of services being created around mobile, but there are two challenges with both.

The challenge with Internet is that there is not enough usage, and that has limited the growth in Internet advertising. The Internet-ad spend in India is about $140 million, which is about 3% of the overall media spend in India, but it’s still quite small. Mobile on the other hand, the value-added-services part, where if you look at non-voice and non-P2P SMS, that’s about a billion dollars. So you have a situation where the consumer spending is roughly seven times that of what businesses are spending. From an entrepreneurial perspective, you see these are two separate opportunities.

So while you create services you will be limited by Internet advertising, which is not growing. Google is getting a larger share of the pie and so on. In the mobile space, the problem becomes the mobile operator. Operators want a larger cut of end-user pays. You’ve got to give billing to the operator. There has to be some innovation, which needs to happen in one or both of these segments. That’s the lay of the land when it comes to India.

Werbach: How do you see that changing? Or do you see that changing? You talked about Japan, and in Japan certainly i-mode was fairly dominant, and still mobile Web services are big there. But also DSL and fiber became very significant.

Jain: In India there are two changes I see happening if I look at the Internet space and the mobile space. In India, on the Internet what we will see happening is the emergence of really mobile broadband. I was talking to one of the telecom providers recently and they have these USB modems, which are basically wireless modems on USB. Typically they’ve been used with laptops – people on the move, enterprise users. Interestingly, when I talked with them they said, “Look, the biggest demand we are getting for these USB modems – because they are high-speed, they are 3G speeds – is from consumers to connect their home PC, the fixed PCs, to the Internet.” Because in many places it is hard to get connectivity. The speeds are just not good. So even though people are willing to pay, the connectivity is pathetic for the most part. So that can drive the growth of the Internet. And devices, low-cost devices, which really are network computers. So we have to solve both the connectivity problem and the device problem for the Internet to grow in India. And then, of course, once that grows, more users start happening. Automatically the ad spends will increase. But that’s the change which needs to happen.

The mobile side is even more interesting. What’s required on the mobile side is to create an ordinate ecosystem for value-added services to the operator. So it’s not really happened, because companies tend to prefer to work with the operator, and once you start working with the operator it’s very difficult to break that relationship.

Two things have happened. The entity DoCoMo showed the potential for an open marketplace where they had tens of thousands of applications which got created, and that drove users. They went from zero to 30 million in about three years, in 1999 to 2002. Apple has shown what’s possible in the U.S. with a model which is basically independent – the App Store model – which is independent of the mobile operator. That is the opportunity which exists today to create what I call a digital-services operator, where there are four elements one needs to put together in the mobile space: alternate payments of collecting money independent of the operator, which Apple is doing in the U.S. through credit cards built up largely first through the iTunes music they sell. The second is having a large reach, so you can reach tens of millions of people cost-effectively so you can make them aware of the services. The third is an open publishing platform and marketplace, so third-party providers, content providers, service providers can comment. And finally, an initial set of compelling services, which get people to want to go create the account.

If these four elements can be put together there is a great opportunity to transform the mobile space and break the stranglehold that mobile operators have. What’s happening today is that, because of their focus primarily on voice and in India mainly launches in rural areas, the top of the pyramid – which is about 100 million people, 25% of the base – want new services but are not able to get to the operators.

So there’s an interesting opportunity which can be created in India and then made to work outside.

Werbach: But how does that happen given the level of control that the operators have, because presumably the operators will resist that change?

Jain: The key thing is to start with two better channels on the mobile, which are in a way almost open. So SMS and voice, because most phones are not using and don’t have data plans in India. But SMS and voice work on all phones. And now if you can create push SMS-based services, which make it almost agnostic. You can make it agnostic of your unit. Businesses are using it to send SMS’s and at very low price points compared to P2P pricing. These prices tend to be much lower because you are buying SMS capacity in bulk. And the incremental cost of sending an SMS through any network globally is close to zero. So there is an interesting thing now where you can create the equivalent of an SMS app store and a voice app store. This is the thing which Apple has basically not done today. They have focused on content so they are limited in a way to only the people who are buying their phones. But an SMS app store could fill what I call life’s free moments. You can create lots of services. Can we create a series of, say, 30 packs of SMS’s, where you can educate people on innovation? You send them an SMS at a fixed time every day and it comes with a link so you get a key idea, which you can read in 15 seconds. And then there’s a link where you can explore for maybe three of four paragraphs, 45 seconds to a minute.

Because it is coming to people and it is permission-based, it opens up a whole new world. On the mobile, people are willing to pay for everything they get. So this starts creating an alternate channel. Now because it’s SMS and push-based, and because it’s voice where you’re dialing up and calling up a voice portal like an IVR system and then listening to stuff, there is no way operators can block any of these things, especially if you have your own payment-collection mechanism. You can make these services-priced. You get all the elements required to start offering services direct to the users without having to rely on all the operators. You need one or two friendly operators for you to push your SMS’s in the system and be able to offer you the voice capabilities. But you can do that in many markets – in most markets – because you always have someone who is willing to compete with the other operators in that market.

Werbach: But at some point, even if you can prove out that model on SMS and voice, presumably there is demand for the smartphone type of applications.

Jain: Absolutely.

Werbach: Especially as you get to 3G and 4G and higher capacity.

Jain: Absolutely. So start with what works today. Again, to go back to the Apple analogy, they started with music. Now they’ve gone into apps and videos and ringtones and all that stuff. Today, in India, SMS subscriptions and voice orders are $350 million to $400 million. That’s money being spent by consumers where the actual content providers and service providers are getting less than 20% of their money. Everyone is looking for a way to monetize mobile users because people have realized that you can’t build a business on the Internet relying only on advertising. It’s got to be consumer-based, and consumers are paying. The question is, “How do you get a fair share or a significant share of the pie to then let you promote the service, to be able to then reinvest back into creating new content?”

The rest of that ecosystem needs to fall into place. But what’s missing is the platform, which basically allows for service discovery, for money collection, for a cash balance to be created. So you make it prepaid – because in India we don’t have too many credit card users – to do exactly what the mobile operators have done. Get people to create a small cash balance so you’re paying $2, putting money into your account. And then as you use the services the money starts being credited. It’s a model they are very familiar with. So the payment model they’re familiar with, content they’re already using, and now because if we don’t have the operator’s share, which is in many cases predatory, you can offer services at very compelling price points, maybe a third of the price points at which today they are being offered in the market. If you can start putting this, I think you’ll see an explosion on the SMS voice site. You have the accounts being created, and then you grow with the market. So then as 3G comes in you can offer video, you can offer apps, and you can offer content downloads, all of that. But start with where things are today and which can work on every phone without the dependency on data plans and high-speed networks.

Werbach: How do you envision things going forward? Is there going to be a global market ultimately of app store providers? Or will this continue to be very much localized depending on the characteristics of the market?

Jain: Very interesting. What we are seeing now is two kinds of apps stores being created, by the handset makers – so like Nokia, Apple – and now already some operators are starting to think of their own app stores. The Vodafones, Verizons and others are probably all thinking of app stores.

I think in both cases what the app stores are doing is being offered to a limited set of users. So in the case of iPhone and Nokia, it is people who bought those phones. People tend to change their phones once in two years. What happens then to your apps and the services you subscribe to? What happens if you change operators? There’s an opportunity to create operator- and handset-agnostic app stores. So essentially take some of the good ideas of the Internet, the open access, etc., make it available on the mobile with one big difference. Have people create a payment or subscription relationship. In retrospect you see that’s something which was missing on the Internet. If operators basically do billing for, say, 10% or 15%, they could get a piece of the pie also. But if they insist on keeping 50% or so of what end users pay, it will create an opportunity for neutral, third-party marketplaces to get created who can create their own case balance and who can offer services which are independent of any of the handset guys or handset companies or the operators. That’s one.

Second, everyone’s focus has been on smartphones and the apps. But what everyone forgets is that in markets like India, 95% of the market doesn’t use such phones. Even in the U.S., 70% of the market does not use it. We’re only going to stay that way for some time. There’s a window of opportunity at least for the next two years. So if you can get in there today – in say the next few months – start building relationships with them, start getting them comfortable with the SMS, voice and, today, services app store, which is independent of your dependency on which service provider you’re using or which handset company you’re using.

That is going to be the real opportunity, which can start in a few countries. But it can actually be global. Theoretically there is nothing that we are doing in India which can’t be offered to any other mobile user anywhere in the world. So that is the big opportunity to monetize mobile users directly independent of the specific operators or the handset companies they have.

227 thoughts on “India’s Mobile Market

  1. Pingback: India's Mobile Market Mobile CHN

  2. Pingback: India's Mobile Market

  3. Pingback: India's Mobile Market

  4. Pingback: Mobile App market in India | Swaroop C H - India, Technology, Life Skills

  5. Pingback: Twitter Trackbacks for India’s Mobile Market [emergic.org] on Topsy.com

  6. Pingback: @Wharton Interview,Rajesh Jain talks about neutral app stores « The MobiKwik Blog

  7. Pingback: @Wharton Interview,Rajesh Jain talks about neutral app stores | The MobiKwik Blog

  8. Hi Rajesh,

    Your answers are very Enlightening for someone who is not in india but interested in market opportunities over there.

    The four points you mentioned are blueprints any startup can use.

    Thanks
    Rohitaash

  9. Pingback: Are We Ready for Operator Independent Application Stores in India? | Telecomblogs

  10. Pingback: Mobile App market in India – Swaroop, The Dreamer

  11. Pingback: Are We Ready for Operator Independent Application Stores in India? – Telecomblogs

  12. Your answers are very Enlightening for someone who is not in india but interested in market opportunities over there.

    The four points you mentioned are blueprints any startup can use.

  13. Kubrick intuited that cinema consists of not only filming the dream, but maintaining its essence, that elusive, uncanny quality that defies words

  14. And also can activate itself in building the country and nation to realize a dignified, prosperous, fair, and respected Indonesia by other nations in the world.

  15. Whether that results what, but still in the game found one winner. Neither with online poker. Keep in mind that in poker games, there are games that only rely on the players alone without relying on anything else.

  16. Very good idea you’ve shared here, from here I can be a very valuable new experience. all things that are here will I make the source of reference, thank you friends.

  17. Pagar BRC with competitively priced anti-rust quality, anti-rust is obtained from finishing the fence itself yani galvanis and hotdeep. Price per sheet both have far superior difference hotdeep. Want full info on BRC fence, factory fence brc gizmo accessories, cheap price.

  18. This A Good Way To Appreciate The Teacher As They Put Their Efforts To Train Students. UK Dissertation Writers Appreciates The Teachers.

    Thanks Share Your Post Very Good

  19. This A Good Way To Appreciate The Teacher As They Put Their Efforts To Train Students. UK Dissertation Writers Appreciates The Teachers.

  20. Situs Referensi Togel SGP HK Prediksi Togel Jitu dan Hasil Live Result Pengeluaran Togel Singapore Hongkong Sidney Kuda Lari Toto Malaysia dll serta informasi Lengkap Alat togel Jitu seperti Buku mimpi Erek Erek 2D 3D 4D Rumus togel SGP HK Sydney, PAITO Togel, Tafsir Mimpi, Kode Alam.

  21. pertamini adalah alat untuk usaha bensin eceran kami menjual berbagai macam type pertamini dengan harga terjangkau.
    bagi yang belum tau apa itu pertamini berikut sy jelaskan.
    dengan adanya pertamini anda tidak perlu repot dalam melayani pembeli, pertamini ini bekerja layaknya di SPBU
    http://pertaminipommini.com

  22. If you are struggling with your leadership assignment and need urgent help then contact us anytime to avail our finest academic writing help. Our aim is to help you in achieving excellent grades and enhance your career growth.

  23. You should write about the model/version on the blog. You can expose it’s perfect. Your blog examination should widen your readership.

  24. I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.

  25. Pingback: Weselne,

  26. Kevin Werbach: I’m very interested in learning from you more about the market in India, where you have been active. Could you talk about how the Internet market and the communications market in India are different from the United States or other countries in the West?

  27. CV. Best Solution Indonesia memberikan layanan service AC di Batam untuk perkantoran, pertokoan, perumahan, hotel, apartement, Perusahaan, Instansi Pemerintah, dll.

    Layanan Service AC Di Batam
    Pelayanan yang kami berikan untuk AC batam Diantaranya:

    Service AC ( AC Split, Window, AC Cassette, AC Central, Standing Floor).
    Isi Freon, Tambah Freon.
    Cuci AC (Cuci standard dan service cuci overhoul).
    Perbaikan AC tidak dingin,  rusak atau mati total.
    Bongkar Pasang AC Batam (bongkar pasang bisa dalam satu lokasi atau beda lokasi).
    Ganti pipa AC.
    Penggantian suku cadang (Spare Parts).
    Las Pipa AC bocor.
    Pemasangan instalasi pipa AC.
    Instalasi Listrik untuk Koneksi AC.
    Jual Beli AC (baru dan bekas/second).

    Kunjungi: https://bestsolutionindonesia.com

  28. Bagi umat Islam, hari Jum’at adalah hari yang istimewa. Karena, ada ibadah yang secara khusus dilakukan hanya pada hari Jum’at. Tentu kamu tahu dong ibadah apa itu? Bener banget, sholat Jum’at bagi lelaki muslim.

    see more: https://waktu.id

  29. Judi Online Indonesia – Judi online indonesia ialah permainan taruhan yang sangatlah menguntungkan untuk di mainkan. Maka dari itu agar anda dapat bermain dengan nyaman tentunya anda membutuhkan situs permainan yang tepat.

  30. Judi Online Indonesia – Judi online indonesia ialah permainan taruhan yang sangatlah menguntungkan untuk di mainkan. Maka dari itu agar anda dapat bermain dengan nyaman tentunya anda membutuhkan situs permainan yang tepat.

  31. Bagi yang menbutuhkan ACP atau Aluminium Composite Panel, kami menyediakan dengan banyak merk type PE dan PVDF. Tebal 3 mm dan 4 mm harga murah untuk seluruh wilayah indonesia, bantu kirim dari Surabaya. Harga murah franco Surabaya dengan ketentuan yang berlaku

  32. Some genuinely choice posts on this web site I really impressed with your writing skills you used to write wonderful and i will come back for more articles. also visit the SEO learning website if you want to know more info about SEO

  33. Pingback: nite Ize inova led tactical Flashlight

  34. thanks for this wonderful site, i really like all about this contents
    this is great site that everyone will like

  35. Pingback: Learn Additional Here

  36. This is my first time i visit here. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here! keep up the good work
    hampton bay

  37. This is very interesting information, I am very impressed reading this topic. thank you for sharing your experiences, next time I will come back to read other interesting information. The best news for you who like to play games, please come here we will help.

  38. Pingback: Google

  39. Greetings! This is my first visit to your blog!

    Your blog provided us useful information to work on.
    You have done a extraordinary job!

    You can also find In fieldengineer.com freelancers for telecom and networking mutual assistance
    http://www.fieldengineer.com is a Global Marketplace which connects businesses and field engineers in telecom industry. The Fastest Growing Startup with a Global Workforce in 175 Countries. We have currently 40000+ engineers signed up worldwide

  40. Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work!
    안전놀이터

  41. This is very interesting content! I have thoroughly enjoyed reading your points and have come to the conclusion that you are right about many of them. You are great.
    메이저사이트

  42. Thank you for the development of the application that you provide, for that you can comet back on my page.
    One of the best and always qualified Indonesian online gambling developers
    INDOBET303 is the largest Indonesian online gaming site that provides

    Slot Online

  43. This blog has been very informative and knowledgable, however in the mobile market there should be a proper net connection with secure browsing, this is where readyshare in the netgear comes to provide stable and ready connection, any solution regarding this issue will be highly appreciated.

  44. Thanks so much for providing individuals with a very remarkable possiblity to discover important secrets from this web site. It can be so ideal and stuffed with amusement for me personally and my office friends to search your blog at a minimum 3 times in 7 days to read through the latest things you will have. Of course, I’m just at all times motivated with the attractive principles you give. Certain two points in this post are ultimately the very best we have all ever had.
    Tech Zone

    ———

  45. Best piece of info ever looking forward for more, If you are looking for a way to remove the lingering odors from your living space, office or in your commercial premises then you are in the right place. Get one from Best Ozone Generator

  46. I have not checked in here for some time since I thought it was getting boring, but the last few posts are great quality so I guess I’ll add you back to my everyday bloglist. You deserve it my friend 🙂

  47. Hey, you used to write excellent, but the last few posts have been kinda boring¡K I miss your super writings. Past few posts are just a little bit out of track! come on!

  48. Do you know if they make any plugins to help with SEO?
    I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted
    keywords but I’m not seeing very good gains.

  49. This blog has been very informative and knowledgable, however in the mobile market there should be a proper net connection with secure browsing, this is where readyshare in the netgear comes to provide stable and ready connection, any solution regarding this issue will be highly appreciated.

  50. Feraripoker adalah sebuah situs poker dengan pencarian paling banyak saat ini yang menawarkan kemudahan pendaftaran untuk para calon pemainnya.

  51. Hey there I am so thrilled I found your blog page, I really
    found you by error, while I was researching on Aol for something else, Regardless I am here now and would just like
    to say thank you for a tremendous post and a all round interesting blog (I also
    love the theme/design), I don’t have time to look over it all at the moment but I have bookmarked it
    and also added in your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read a lot
    more, Please do keep up the great work.

  52. What’s up to every body, it’s my first visit of this web site;
    this blog carries remarkable and truly excellent data in favor of visitors.