Logistics might sound a simple enough business of moving things around, but it is growing more complex as customers demand more finely tuned services, and as new technology and greater use of the Internet open up new ways of passing around information. Now that companies have delayered, re-engineered and scrubbed the waste from their assembly lines, logistics seems worthy of rather closer attention.
To simplify what goes into the factory and make it more of a snap-together assembly line, [companies] outsource more, and buy in sub-assemblies rather than individual parts. They are also trying to build only to orders from customers (known as BTO), rather than guessing what will be in demand and supplying it from accumulated stocks. Cutting inventories and introducing BTO calls for a comprehensive, flexible freight operation. This is such a challenging task that companies are reluctant to do it all themselves. So more of them are, in effect, outsourcing logistics to third parties.
This movement is forcing the freight-transport industry to reshape, as customers seek service suppliers with global reach. Manufacturers want custom-designed delivery systems, using all types of transportland, sea and air. Distinctions between postal, express and logistics services are blurring. And the fastest-growing part of the business is catering to the demand for outsourcing by providing companies with third-party logistics.
Companies realise that organising the supply of incoming parts and outgoing goods can account for 10% of their costs. Yet they know little about how best to do it, according to Mr Bakker of TPG, the world’s second-largest logistics specialist (under its TNT Logistics brand). He says the biggest omission is not counting the cost of holding more inventory than is needed. Even car makers, for all their lean factories, produce cars that sit idle for up to 100 days.
Nowadays, with global supply-chains connecting cheap workers on one side of the world with rich consumers on the other, good logistics can make all the difference to a company’s ability to serve its customers. It is not just what you make or how you make it. It is how quickly you get the parts together, or shift finished products from Asian factories to western markets. The success of retailers such as Wal-Mart in America or Marks & Spencer in Britain depends largely on getting the right goods to the right place on time.
Category: Microsoft
Ballmer and Microsoft
An interesting NYTimes story on the “softer” Microsoft and Steve Ballmer:
The newest Ballmer buzzword is ”wallow,” as in what you’ve got to do to solve a really tough, complicated problem — take days, weeks even, to ”wallow” in it, with all the hippo connotations of tremendous physical presence and without the traditional Microsoft pressure to right then and there devise and implement some genius solution. In the old days, Ballmer, say his current colleagues, would sight-read your spreadsheets and tell you that what you were doing was simply wrong. Now Ballmer prefers to wallow.
Within Microsoft, the tightly disciplined members of the executive staff are very much on message. They are deadly earnest in their conviction that Ballmer doesn’t yell anymore. Instead of dominating all discussions, they say, he asks leading questions designed to teach his charges how to approach problems.
Bill Gates in India
Bill Gates visited India last week, gave USD 100 million to fight AIDS and announced an investment of USD 400 million for various Microsoft initiatives – in education, setting up Academies, doing .Net projects, and growing its Hyderabad centre. [Business Week story: Bill Gates’s Indian Coronation]
What is not clear is how much of the USD 400 million is in cash and how much is in the form of Microsoft products.
The by-products of the visit:
– Indians see Bill Gates as a messiah for all the problems facing us
– No one in a position of power or influence wants to talk Linux and open-source, because their eyes are on the USD 400 million
– Indians feel greatly obliged to Gates for his contribution to the IT sector, and are therefore trying to fall over backwards to see how they can help him
– Few, if any, bothered to listen to Richard Stallman of the Free Software Foundation [more]
We are so short-sighted. We confuse Bill Gates’ USD 100 million AIDS philanthropy (which is very good) and his USD 400 million plan to conquer the Indian software market (which we think is also philanthropy). Microsoft is making the investment to control three key sectors in India: education, government and banking. They are among the most critical – the first for its influence in creating the next set of programmers (who Microsoft wants to raise on Windows) and the other two for their spending power.
India had a great opportunity to show the world its mettle: it should have rejected Gates’ largesse for education, and made a forthright announcement on using Linux and open-source in its schools. That would have set an example of leadership worldwide among emerging markets. But for some little near-term gains (which may or may not materialise), we are mortgaging the future. The education sector is critical – what Microsoft wants to do is to hardwire Windows and Office in the curriculum. A few years ago, with the alternatives not being good enough, one could have understood that. But now, there is no excuse.
Use Microsoft products for the international market when we do services, but when it comes to domestic decisions where cost is a very important consideration, India must go the open-source way. We need cost-effective computing solutions to make computing available to all – in the words of Bill Gates, “have a computer on every desk and in every home”. India’s strong stance on open-source would have forced Microsoft’s hand, and perhaps, made it reduce pricing on products for India and other emerging markets. Instead, we are only strengthening its hand, and jeopordising the very base that India needs to be more competitive in the future.
Full credit to Microsoft and Bill Gates: they’ve mastered the art of selling and “crossing the last mile”. I can think of no other industry where the buyers travel from all over and go to the seller from all over the country with blank cheques in return for a photo-op or a handshake or a sales pitch!
Windows’ 85% Margin
From NYTimes: “Microsoft has revealed for the first time that it has made profit margins of 85 per cent on its Windows system while its remaining businesses made losses, raising questions about the benefits of the group’s costly efforts at diversification. The client division, which markets Windows, generated operating profits last quarter of $2.48bn on revenues of $2.89bn, implying margins of 85 per cent.”
Some other figures:
Among Microsoft’s other businesses, the home and entertainment di vision, which includes the Xbox games console, lost $177m in the quarter on revenues of $505m. Salomon Smith Barney estimates it loses about $120 on each console it sells.
MSN, the internet service provider and portal, lost $97m, down from losses of $199m in the same quarter last year, on revenues up from $431m to $531m.
The business solutions group, which provides software for small and medium-sized businesses and includes recent acquisitions Great Plains of the US and Navision of Denmark, lost $68m on revenues of $107m.
And the CE/Mobility division, which includes mobile telephone software and the Windows CE operating system for handheld computers, lost $33m on revenues of $17m.
The Information Worker division (which comprises MS-Office) had revenues of USD 2.38 billion, with profits of USD 1.88 billion (79%). Adds News.com: “The business units making up Windows and Office brought in $4.88 billion in profits for Microsoft. But $830 million in losses for the four other divisions reduced earnings to $4.05 billion, according to Microsoft’s 10-Q.”
Microsoft’s Leaked Open Source Memo
The document was presented at a Microsoft internal Linux Strategic Review held at the Microsoft offices in Berlin during Sept. 2002. The memo was leaked to Eric Raymond, an open source advocate and author of “The Cathedral and the Bazaar“.
Writes InfoWorld about the memo:
“The overall tone of the memorandum is very defensive,” Eric Raymond said in advising open source advocates on his conclusions to the survey. It’s “not quite panicky, but the researchers are not able to name any argument with the open source community that their own figures show them to be winning. In fact, their figures indicate that we are winning. It looks like all we have to do is stay the course.”
The memo describes the results of a telephone survey of developers; system, network and database administrators; and business executives who make decisions on IT spending. The project was developed to provide a greater understanding of how key “audiences” perceive open source, Linux, shared source and general public licenses, and which messages will be effective with each audience, an executive summary of the memo said. The survey was conducted in the U.S., Brazil, France, Germany, Sweden and Japan.
The researchers who conducted the survey found that familiarity and favorability for open source software (OSS) and Linux was high across geographies and audiences. They also found that respondents cited open source software’s “low total cost of ownership” (TCO) as one of the best reasons to support OSS, but because it is an “alternative to Microsoft” was second. Forty percent of all respondents felt that a low TCO was the best reason to support OSS and one-third of all respondents cited “an alternative to Microsoft” as one of the best reasons to support OSS.
Microsoft’s Challenges
To prevent open standards and Linux from dethroning Microsoft in the way that the PC and Microsoft toppled IBM, the firm is trying to develop other strongholds. One attempt is the .NET platform and its related web-based information services, which have failed to take off so far. Another could be anti-piracy technology (which is why Palladium, the firm’s secure-PC initiative, has caused such a stir). A third could be Yukon, a new database technology.
If it is to keep growing fast, a tall order for a firm with yearly revenues of $30 billion, Microsoft must meet a second challenge: expanding beyond its traditional markets. One new area is high-end enterprise software. More importantly, it has also moved into several non-PC markets, including handheld computers, interactive television, games consoles and, most importantly, smart mobile phones. But in each case, so far, it has failed.
The Economist article talks about “the long shadow of Big Blue” and asks if Microsoft might go the way IBM did in the 1980s. IBM has since made a strong comeback – IBM and Microsoft are the technology superpowers now.
Even as Microsoft look at new markets, it needs to remember that its next users will come from the world’s emerging markets. In countries like India, customers cannot afford to pay hundreds of dollars for MS-Office. This is where Microsoft faces the “Innovator’s Dilemma”. Its primary products (Windows and Office) are more than good enough for its existing markets. And it hasn’t yet created products for the next markets, which need something at a tenth of the price.
Microsoft’s New Hurdles
The rise of the Internet has affected the technology industry in three main ways, each of which tends to discourage monopoly power. First, no single company controls the Internet’s crucial technical standards. Second, it is a low-cost technology and though essentially a communications technology, it has helped accelerate the advance of low-cost economics in computing generally. Third, as a decentralized technology, the Internet holds the promise of dispersing market power.
Today’s embodiment of the Internet threat to Microsoft is Linux, an increasingly popular operating system and a real potential rival to Microsoft’s Windows. The business problem of competing against Linux is far trickier for Microsoft than was thwarting the early Internet challenge from browsing software and Netscape Communications, the commercial pioneer in browsers.
This time, for example, the competitive weapons in the Microsoft arsenal will be fewer because a federal appeals court has ruled that the bullying of industry partners and rivals to protect its monopoly was illegal. And Linux, an operating system written and updated by a worldwide community of volunteer programmers and distributed free, is a more elusive target. It already has broad industry support, and no single company stands behind it.
The Linux strategy is to undercut Microsoft, just as Microsoft was once regarded as a leading practitioner of low-cost economics in pricing its personal computer operating systems for high-volume sales.
Brian Behlendorf, a leader in the open-source development community, says the advance of Linux may well force Microsoft to take a drastic step to meet the competition. “My prediction is that within three years time, Microsoft will `give away’ its operating system to preserve its revenue in the applications business,” Mr. Behlendorf said.
Microsoft Case
There has a lot of talk on Friday’s judgement in the Microsoft case. Frankly, I feel we are missing the point. What has happened is fait accompli. What companies have to do is to look ahead. The marketplace is the ultimate judge. Microsoft can be beaten – companies have to innovate, listen to their customers, and open up new markets. Microsoft’s size means that it will not initially go after smaller markets or do anything to upset its gravy train of profits. That is where the opportunities for emerging software companies lie.
Microsoft has only won the battle for the world’s first 500 million customers.Sure, it starts off in a strong position for Technology’s Next Markets, but it is not guaranteed success. This is what we must look at. Think Clay Christensen’s “The Innovator’s Dilemma”.
Microsoft’s SME Business
Writes Forbes about the challenge that Douglas Burgum (former CEO of Great Plains which Microsoft bought) faces – boost sales by $10 billion in ten years:
Says his boss, [Jeff] Raikes: “The goal is about what the world will be like in 2010. You won’t pick a doctor, lawyer, contractor or insurance agent unless you can electronically communicate with them. Small and medium-size businesses will embrace the Internet.”
The focus Burgum has is on SMEs. We too want to create enterprise software for SMEs – the ones in the emerging markets who will not be able to pay for Microsoft’s products.
I like the point made by Raikes – imagine what the world will be in 2010. Many-a-time, we fail because we don’t think or dream big enough or far ahead. The first step to build the future is to envision it.
Microsoft’s Monopoly Profits
Microsoft Piggy Bank Tops $40 Billion, says Dan Gillmor. “The monopoly continues, unabated, and could even grow stronger. Innovation is almost dead in desktop software, where Microsoft has sucked the financial oxygen out of the system. The company’s behavior doesn’t improve.”
Suggests John Robb:
What if Microsoft took $300 m and provided a $3 m grant to 100 small independent companies doing the most innovative software on Windows? What if they promoted their products to customers? There are still lots of things that Microsoft doesn’t do. Could this restart the PC upgrade cycle? I think it could. The great part about this is that Microsoft would make back that money in less than three years through upgrades. The PR bonanza would be huge.
However, this won’t happen. Microsoft has now yielded to NIH (Not Invented Here) disease. They think that the $5 b a year that they squander on R&D will actually yield a real innovation — it won’t. Hey Ballmer: most of the smart people in the world of technology don’t work at Microsoft. Real innovation is going on right now in the trenches, as it always has. However, it is growing slower than it should because the air supply has been turned off.
Even as others in the tech industry feel the pain, Microsoft gets stronger and stronger. [Vinod Khosla: 8,000 out of the 10,000 tech cos. in the US need to die.] We can all talk about what Microsoft needs to do. It is a waste of time. But remember that every monopolist has only a limited time at the top.
The way to counter Microsoft is in the world’s next markets. These are markets which cannot afford to pay for Microsoft’s products, and Microsoft cannot afford to reduce their prices for these “negligible” markets. This is where the opportunities of tomorrow lie for innovative software companies. There is very little legacy, so one can re-think all the components for the desktop and the enterprise. Use the newest ideas (blogs, web services) and create low-cost software solutions which consumers and enterprises in the emerging markets can use.
The good think about targeting the bottom of the pyramid is that (a) there is zero competition (b) there is huge opportunity – in terms of users, at least as big as the existing computer markets of today – in excess of 500 million (c) at some point, the products will become good enough for the mainstream also in case one feels playing the Monopolist.
You must be logged in to post a comment.